Unfortunately the audio of the week 7 lectures have not been recorded. The slides are available, however, on both MULO and Blackboard. I am very sorry for the inconvenience, but sometimes technology does fail. I know that some of you have clashes and need to rely on the recordings. I would urge, however, those of you who can attend the lectures to do so, because that is the only absolutely guaranteed way that you have of hearing the material
Cheers, Clare
Friday, 20 April 2012
Wednesday, 18 April 2012
Crusades and Crusade Historians
[Edit: spelling corrected for Tyerman - thanks Jonathan!]
In lectures during week 7 Clare raised the issue of thinking about where historians are coming from when they write. I'd like us to try and incorporate this into our discussions in this week's virtual tutorial. I've provided some links that give you other people's perspectives on Christopher Tyerman, author of the chapter on the Meaning of the Crusades, and his work. There are reviews of one of his recent books by Jonathan Philips - another well-known historian of the Crusades - and Dame Janet (a.k.a. 'Jinty') Nelson, a prominent early medievalist. I've also given you a link to an interview with Dr Tyerman himself. If you can, I recommend reading through these after you've looked at Tyerman's chapter. Address the questions in the reading pack, but also consider whether Tyerman's view seems to represent a consensus; and how his views differ from or relate to those of others who have written and thought about the Crusades.
The same was true at the time of the very first crusade. As Megan told us a couple of weeks back, pope Urban's sermon was recorded in different versions by a range of observers. Does applying similar principles of interpretation to these reports help you think about how and why they differ? Where were these medieval writers coming from, do you think? Why were they writing? Who was in their assumed audience?
Post your thoughts and responses to these readings below by Monday evening. Then we'll be moving on to St Francis and Co.!
Truce between Christians and Saracens.
Matthew Paris, Chronica Maiora, Parker MS 16II, f.139v.
|
-
- Review of God's War by Jonathan Phillips in The Telegraph, September 2006.
- Review of God's War by J.L. Nelson in the London Review of Books, 2007.
- Interview with Christopher Tyerman about his book God's War.
![]() |
| Urban II preaching at Clermont |
In this interview, Tyerman talks about how it is misleading and ahistorical to draw direct connections between modern wars in the Middle East and the medieval crusading movement. I agree with him on this point, and it brings me to a general matter I forgot to mention in class, which is: while modern parallels and experiences can be useful tools for helping us think about the past, we should never confuse them with historical argument itself, which always has to be based in the evidence and context of the period. I'm sure you knew this - but especially following our discussions about ANZAC cove and Canterbury it seemed a good time to remind ourselves of this point...
![]() |
| Urban II preaching the crusade |
But back to the Crusades! The Institute for Historical Research in London runs a monthly seminar about the Crusades, so clearly there's no shortage of opinion and debate on the topic.
Post your thoughts and responses to these readings below by Monday evening. Then we'll be moving on to St Francis and Co.!
Tuesday, 10 April 2012
Gender Roles
This week sees the first of the blogs composed by you,
the students! You get to take over our online interactions, and direct
our discussion from the outset. Please be considerate of your
colleagues' efforts and be sure to contribute generously online and in
class.
Kathleen
Emily writes:
The gender expectations of this time were that
women were to run the households and to raise the children; marriage was about
financial and political connections and love was something reserved for Christ.
But with the rise of interest in courtly and romantic love, marriage was
idealized as being a symbol of love and expression of passion, thereby altering
the gender expectations of women being bought and sold as wives, but as women
who were something to be desired and loved. We’ve looked at the story of
Abelard and Heloise, and another I think it would be interesting to look at is
the poem about Sir Lancelot and Queen Guinevere:
Sir Lancelot and Queen
Guinevere by Lord Alfred Tennyson
Like souls that balance joy
and pain,
With tears and smiles from
heaven again
The maiden Spring upon the
plain
Came in a sunlit fall of
rain.
In crystal vapor everywhere
Blue isles of heaven
laugh'd between,
And far, in forest-deeps
unseen,
The topmost elm-tree gather'd
green
From draughts of balmy air.
Sometimes the linnet piped
his song;
Sometimes the throstle
whistled strong;
Sometimes the sparhawk,
wheel'd along,
Hush'd all the groves from
fear of wrong;
By grassy capes with fuller
sound
In curves the yellowing
river ran,
And drooping chestnut-buds
began
To spread into the perfect
fan,
Above the teeming ground.
Then, in the boyhood of the
year,
Sir Launcelot and Queen
Guinevere
Rode thro' the coverts of
the deer,
With blissful treble
ringing clear.
She seem'd a part of joyous
Spring;
A gown of grass-green silk
she wore,
Buckled with golden clasps
before;
A light-green tuft of
plumes she bore
Closed in a golden ring.
Now on some twisted
ivy-net,
Now by some tinkling
rivulet,
In mosses mixt with violet
Her cream-white mule his
pastern set;
And fleeter now she skimm'd
the plains
Than she whose elfin
prancer springs
By night to eery warblings,
When all the glimmering
moorland rings
With jingling bridle-reins.
As she fled fast thro' sun
and shade,
The happy winds upon her
play'd,
Blowing the ringlet from
the braid.
She look'd so lovely, as
she sway'd
The rein with dainty
finger-tips,
A man had given all other
bliss,
And all his worldly worth
for this,
To waste his whole heart in
one kiss
Upon her perfect lips.
We’ve already looked at Abelard and Heloise, but
the story of Lancelot and Guinevere idealized the passion and lust that was so
highly sought after with the notion of romantic and courtly love.
Throughout the early, or the low middle ages the life of many consisted of
being raised by your parents, married off to secure money, political
connections, more land or other materialistic acquisitive means, and then the
men ran the farms or worked the land, and the women raised the children. There
were slight variations throughout socio-economic groups of course, but that was
a generic and largely accepted routine. Within the readings, focus on the
contrasts drawn between Lady Eve (from the Garden of Eden) and the Virgin Mary.
One was condemned for the downfall of man, while the other was praised with
bringing the Messiah to man and how this might have changed or been affected
through the concepts of marriage. This also relates to virginity, which many of
Gen Y may not think all that much about nowadays, could have resulted in
women’s perceived ‘value’ being lowered and fines being paid to her father as
compensation back in the day.
~ ~ ~
Clare adds:
The following are some questions which you may see
as a guideline in pinpointing some aspects of this week's text. Whilst you don’t have
to write out exact answers for these questions, please take time to consider
each of them, and what the author/s of this week’s reading opinions are.
- How did the ‘cult of Mary’ or the ‘cult of virginity’ influence the lives of medieval women? Did the birth of Christ, from the Virgin Mary, lift women’s lowly position in medieval society or were they still scorned as the ancestors of the first sinner, Eve?
- What are the key determinants for marriage during the High Middle Ages? Did the Church’s views differ from that of the heads of families and clans?
- How did the duties of wives and women differ among the classes? Did activities such as needlework and tapestry making (among the upper classes) or being a wet-nurse (among lower classes) further hinder their freedom or enhance it?
- It was expected that a good obedient wife would conceive and bear many children. How did this constant state of pregnancy affect women? Was motherhood a type of outlet for the medieval woman or was it just another shackle to endure?
| Christine de Pizan hard at work |
Also, consider these quotes from Christine de Pizan. She
appears to be quite a unique and talented woman. Would you agree? Is she a rare
example of an intelligent woman of her time, or just one lucky enough to be
granted the right to education and thus able to express her feelings through
prose and text?
“The man or the woman in whom resides greater
virtue is the higher; neither the loftiness nor the lowliness of a person lies
in the body according to the sex, but in the perfection of conduct and virtues.”
“How many women are there ... who because of
their husbands' harshness spend their weary lives in the bond of marriage in
greater suffering than if they were slaves among the Saracens?”
Finally, if you have the time (or inclination),
check out episode 2 of the documentary Kathleen mentioned (http://topdocumentaryfilms.com/inside-the-medieval-mind/),
as it discusses gender roles in medieval Europe, and is rather
interesting.
Friday, 6 April 2012
Easter Week
Hi everyone,
I hope you're having a nice break - but not too much of a break, because essays are looming! Use time off lectures and tutorials to get ahead on your research if you can. In the meanwhile, here's some medieval Easter music to pass the time...
The image shows a manuscript called a Gradual,
which is a collection of musical items for the Mass. There are two
musical pieces on the page. The decorated capital R is the beginning of
the introit for Easter Sunday. An introit, as you might guess
from the name, is sung at the beginning of the Mass. This one comes from
Psalm 138, and reads, in Latin:
Resurrexi, et adhuc tecum sum, alleluia. Posuisti super me manum tuam, alleluia. Mirabilis facta est scientia tua, alleluia. Domine probasti me et cognivisti me.
Then, with the large black "h", begins another psalm, no. 118:
Haec dies quam fecit Dominus: exultemus et laetemur in ea
Can you make out any of the words, now that you know what it should say?
See you on Monday week,
Kathleen
I hope you're having a nice break - but not too much of a break, because essays are looming! Use time off lectures and tutorials to get ahead on your research if you can. In the meanwhile, here's some medieval Easter music to pass the time...
![]() |
| Resurrexi, Music for Easter Sunday, British Library, Crowland Gradual, c.1240. |
Resurrexi, et adhuc tecum sum, alleluia. Posuisti super me manum tuam, alleluia. Mirabilis facta est scientia tua, alleluia. Domine probasti me et cognivisti me.
[I
rose up and am still with thee, alleluia. Thou hast laid thy hand upon
me, alleluia. Thy knowledge is become wonderful to me, alleluia. Lord,
thou hast proved me, and known me]
Listen to a performance of a medieval setting of this psalm by Schola Cantorum hereThen, with the large black "h", begins another psalm, no. 118:
Haec dies quam fecit Dominus: exultemus et laetemur in ea
[This is the day that the Lord made: let us be glad and rejoice in it.]
Listen to a performance of a later (16th century) setting of this psalm by The King's Singers hereCan you make out any of the words, now that you know what it should say?
See you on Monday week,
Kathleen
Tuesday, 3 April 2012
The Passion
The Passion, for those who don't know, is a term for Jesus' crucifixion on Good Friday. In medieval times one of the symbols of this was the pelican. A widespread story, often illustrated in Bestiaries, related how the pelican fed her starving young with her own blood; this was taken as a metaphor of Christ's sacrifice. The Pelican in her Piety, as this story was called, became a common artistic motif in medieval religious architecture, and in encyclopaedic books. The image here shows the Pelican in her Piety
represented in a misericord at St Mary's Abbey, Beverley, in Yorkshire,
a famous example of 14th century English Gothic style. She is pecking
her own breast to release the blood and feed the chicks. (They weren't
shy of graphic images in those days!)
A misericord is a little folding seat in the quire (i.e. choir) area of churches that the monks or canons could lean on during long services. It comes from the Latin for mercy,
because allowing a tired singer to sit down was like taking mercy on
him! In the medieval period the underneath of misericords, like the one
shown here, came to be decorated in marvellous carvings, since this was
the part of the seat most often visible to those moving about the church
between services. Some had religious images, and others had very
surprisingly secular ones, like illustrations from tales of knightly
deeds and the rescue of fair maidens, or images of monsters.
![]() |
| Pelican in her Piety, St Mary's, Beverley. By awmc1 @ flickr |
Wednesday, 28 March 2012
Comments!
If you are still having trouble commenting on the blog, your browser may be incompatible.
Follow this link to check which browser(s) to use: http://support.google.com/blogger/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=42247
Week 6 tutorial blog follows below...
Follow this link to check which browser(s) to use: http://support.google.com/blogger/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=42247
Week 6 tutorial blog follows below...
Tuesday, 27 March 2012
Library Tutorial Week
Hi everyone,
A reminder that our week 6 tutorial will take place in the Mattheson library in the ground floor Training Room 1 (a library floor plan is here). It's compulsory to attend this class and complete a worksheet based on what you learn. The aim is to give you the skills you will need to research your essay and reference it properly using the expected footnote style. It's a very important week for setting you up to study history in general as well as specifically to prepare for your essay in this unit. To get ready for next week, first use Monash's Search system to try and identify any book about Charlemagne that was published in the last 10 years and is available in the Mattheson library. Then try to find a journal article about Carolingian law written in the same period. Write down all the publication details you can find for these two items. Try to articulate what strategies you used to find the two items, and any difficulties you encountered. Come prepared with your results and any post any questions or problems that want solving below. In addition...
if this is your first year at Uni: Try to define these terms for yourself:
if none of this is new to you: Think about your experience of researching and writing an essay. What are your top tips for finding relevant books and other sources? What problems have you encountered when referencing essays? What useful feedback from tutors have you gained? Be ready to share your expertise with the rest.
And since there is no required reading, here are some links you might want to peruse to keep you thinking medieval!
A reminder that our week 6 tutorial will take place in the Mattheson library in the ground floor Training Room 1 (a library floor plan is here). It's compulsory to attend this class and complete a worksheet based on what you learn. The aim is to give you the skills you will need to research your essay and reference it properly using the expected footnote style. It's a very important week for setting you up to study history in general as well as specifically to prepare for your essay in this unit. To get ready for next week, first use Monash's Search system to try and identify any book about Charlemagne that was published in the last 10 years and is available in the Mattheson library. Then try to find a journal article about Carolingian law written in the same period. Write down all the publication details you can find for these two items. Try to articulate what strategies you used to find the two items, and any difficulties you encountered. Come prepared with your results and any post any questions or problems that want solving below. In addition...
| Love and Devotion is on at the State Library of Victoria |
- reference
- citation
- primary source
- footnote
- plagiarism
- secondary source
- bibliography
if none of this is new to you: Think about your experience of researching and writing an essay. What are your top tips for finding relevant books and other sources? What problems have you encountered when referencing essays? What useful feedback from tutors have you gained? Be ready to share your expertise with the rest.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
And since there is no required reading, here are some links you might want to peruse to keep you thinking medieval!
- For those of you fascinated by the difference between the East and West in the medieval period, you might want to look at the exhibition currently showing at the State Library of Victoria, Love and Devotion, which is a lavish display of Persian manuscripts from the 11th century onwards. It looks at Eastern literature on its own terms, and in relationship to contemporary and modern Western society. It's free and it's on until the 1st of July.
- For those interested in the weird and wonderful world of religious relics, you might be interested in this review of Treasures of Heaven, a recent exhibition of reliquaries (i.e. containers for relics) that was held at the British Museum in 2011.
You can watch the official introduction to the Treasures of Heaven exhibition here:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




